Augusta Precious Metals vs American Bullion. Which Is The Best?

Reading Time: 6 minutes

Last Updated on October 15, 2025

Choosing the right gold IRA company is one of the most important financial decisions you’ll make for retirement.

Get it wrong, and you risk hidden fees, poor customer service, or worse, entrusting your savings to a company that won’t be there when you need them.

That’s why in this comparison, we’re putting Augusta Precious Metals, a company widely recognized for its white-glove service and transparency, head-to-head with American Bullion, an established firm that’s been helping investors diversify with gold and silver for nearly two decades.

Both companies are legitimate, trusted names in the precious metals IRA industry, but they cater to slightly different types of investors.

By the end of this guide, you’ll see exactly where each provider shines, which one fits your goals, and most importantly, who comes out as the clear winner for building a safe, secure retirement portfolio.

Stay with me because in the next few minutes, you’ll have the confidence to choose wisely and take action to protect your financial future.

Quick Comparison Table

Feature	Augusta Precious Metals	American Bullion
Founded	2012	2009
Minimum Investment	$50000	$25000
Fees	Transparent, flat annual fee (no hidden charges)	Annual fees apply, structure less transparent
Metals Offered	Gold & Silver (IRA + direct purchase)	Gold, Silver, Platinum, Palladium (IRA + direct purchase)
Buyback Policy	Lifetime buyback guarantee	Buyback program available (not lifetime guaranteed)
BBB/Trustpilot Rating	A+ BBB, 4.9/5 Trustpilot	A+ BBB, 4.7/5 Trustpilot
Best For	Conservative retirees who value transparency & white-glove service	Investors seeking lower entry minimums & wider metal variety

Company Background & Trust Signals

Augusta Precious Metals

Augusta Precious Metals was founded in 2012 and has quickly become one of the most trusted names in the gold IRA industry.

The company is widely recognized for its education-first approach, lifetime customer support, and straightforward fee structure.

Endorsements from respected figures like NFL Hall-of-Famer Joe Montana add to its credibility.

Augusta holds an A+ rating from the BBB and a near-perfect 4.9/5 on Trustpilot, reflecting its reputation for trustworthiness and client satisfaction.

American Bullion

American Bullion, established in 2009, is one of the early pioneers of the gold IRA space and is credited with popularizing the concept.

With more than a decade of experience, it offers a broader range of precious metals, including platinum and palladium, alongside gold and silver.

American Bullion also maintains an A+ BBB rating and strong customer reviews (4.7/5 on Trustpilot) while being featured in respected outlets such as Forbes.

Verdict:

Minimum Investment & Setup Process

Augusta Precious Metals

Augusta Precious Metals requires a $50,000 minimum investment for opening a gold IRA.

While this higher entry point may limit accessibility for smaller investors, it’s designed to attract serious, long-term retirement savers.

The setup process is straightforward and highly guided: Augusta’s specialists walk clients through each step, from IRA rollover to choosing metals, ensuring there’s no confusion along the way.

American Bullion

American Bullion sets the bar lower with a $25,000 minimum investment, making it more accessible to a wider range of investors.

Their account setup is fast, often completed within 24–48 hours, and they provide hands-on support during the rollover or transfer process.

This makes American Bullion appealing to investors who want to start with a smaller allocation or move quickly.

Verdict: It’s a tie

Fees & Pricing Comparison

Augusta Precious Metals

Augusta Precious Metals is known for its clear and upfront fee structure.

• Setup fee: $50 (one-time)
• Annual administrative fee: $100
• Annual storage fee: $100 for non-segregated storage, $150 for segregated storage

This brings the total to about $250–$300 per year, depending on storage type.

There are no hidden costs or surprise markups, making Augusta one of the most transparent providers in the industry.

American Bullion

American Bullion follows a more standard model in the gold IRA space.

• Setup fee: $50 (one-time)
• Annual administrative fee: $95
• Annual storage fee: $100 for non-segregated storage, $150 for segregated storage

While the fees are competitive, American Bullion does not publish every detail as openly as Augusta, which may leave some investors with questions until they speak directly with a representative.

Verdict:

Custodian & Storage Options

Augusta Precious Metals

Augusta Precious Metals partners with the highly respected Equity Trust as its preferred custodian, a firm with over 45 years of experience managing self-directed IRAs.

For storage, Augusta uses Delaware Depository, one of the most secure and IRS-approved facilities in the U.S.

Investors can choose between segregated and non-segregated storage, with assets fully insured by Lloyd’s of London.

This combination of reputable custodianship and robust storage provides investors with maximum confidence in the safety of their retirement metals.

American Bullion

American Bullion also works with Equity Trust and offers storage through Delaware Depository and Brink’s Global Services.

Like Augusta, American Bullion provides both segregated and non-segregated storage options, with accounts fully insured against theft or loss.

This gives investors flexibility in choosing storage arrangements, with Brink’s providing international storage options for those who want additional diversification.

Verdict:

Metals Selection & Flexibility

Augusta Precious Metals

Augusta Precious Metals focuses exclusively on gold and silver coins and bars that meet IRS approval for retirement accounts.

While the selection is narrower compared to some competitors, Augusta’s strategy is intentionalas it emphasizes simplicity, liquidity, and premium-quality products.

Investors can also purchase gold and silver for direct delivery outside of their IRA, making it a solid choice for those who want to diversify both within and outside retirement accounts.

American Bullion

American Bullion, on the other hand, offers a broader selection of metals, including gold, silver, platinum, and palladium.

This makes it a more attractive option for investors who want to explore a wider variety of precious metals within their IRA.

American Bullion also provides the option to buy for direct delivery, giving customers flexibility beyond retirement accounts.

Verdict: It’s a tie

Buyback Program & Liquidity

Augusta Precious Metals

Augusta Precious Metals offers a lifetime buyback guarantee, allowing investors to sell their gold or silver back at competitive market prices at any time.

This guarantee provides assured liquidity and peace of mind, especially for retirees who may need quick access to funds without worrying about market manipulation or unfair pricing.

American Bullion

American Bullion also has a reliable buyback program, allowing investors to sell metals at fair market value.

However, it does not offer a lifetime guarantee, meaning that while liquidity is strong, the assurance and confidence provided by Augusta’s program is slightly higher.

Verdict:

Education & Customer Support

Augusta Precious Metals

Augusta Precious Metals is renowned for its high-touch, educational approach:

• One-on-one consultations with a dedicated specialist

• Free Gold IRA kit with step-by-step instructions

• Webinars, guides, and articles covering market trends, IRA rules, and investment strategies

This personalized guidance ensures that investors fully understand every step of their IRA setup and metals investing, building confidence and trust.

American Bullion

American Bullion offers solid educational resources and customer support, including:

• Free guides and articles explaining gold, silver, platinum, and palladium investing

• Account specialists to assist with IRA rollovers and setup

• Responsive customer service for account-related inquiries

While American Bullion provides helpful support, it is less personalized and hands-on than Augusta’s white-glove approach, making Augusta the better choice for investors who want guided mentorship.

Verdict:

Pros & Cons and Who Each Company is Best For

Augusta Precious Metals

• Lifetime buyback guarantee for maximum liquidity

• Transparent fees with no hidden costs

• White-glove, personalized support and education

• High credibility and trust with endorsements and top ratings

• Simple, focused metals selection (gold & silver)

• Higher minimum investment ($50,000)

• Limited metals selection compared to competitors (no platinum or palladium)

Best For:

• Conservative retirees looking for security and transparency

• Investors seeking hands-on guidance and education

• Those prioritizing peace of mind and long-term trust

American Bullion

• Lower minimum investment ($25,000)

• Broader metals selection including platinum and palladium

• Strong educational resources and responsive support

• Established provider with a solid track record

• Less personalized support compared to Augusta

• Fees are slightly less transparent upfront

• Buyback program not a lifetime guarantee

Best For:

• Investors with smaller accounts or lower initial capital

• Those seeking greater metals variety

• Investors comfortable with some self-directed guidance

Overall Winner!

While both companies are reputable, Augusta Precious Metals is the safer and smarter pick for most retirement investors.

Its lifetime buyback guarantee, transparent fees, and white-glove support make it the top choice for serious investors who want security, clarity, and peace of mind.

American Bullion is better suited for investors prioritizing variety and lower entry costs, but it doesn’t match Augusta’s level of hands-on service.

Take action today

Securing your retirement is too important to leave to chance.

With Augusta Precious Metals, you gain trusted guidance, transparent fees, and a lifetime buyback guarantee, all designed to give you peace of mind and confidence in your retirement savings.

The earlier you start, the sooner your retirement savings are shielded from inflation and market volatility. Don’t wait, get your kit and start investing in your financial security today.